The Best Blender for Nut Butter 2023 (our blender performance test) – Almond Butter & Peanut Butter

Finding the best blender for nut butter to blend at home is not only a budget-friendly option, but it also allows makes for a more nutritious option.

Many times, processed nut butter includes disastrous ingredients that claim to “improve” flavor and texture. More on that below.

Unfortunately, the jar of “all-natural” nut butter that you so dearly love and use religious most likely has horrendous ingredients that are devastating for your health. For example, palm oil, added sugar, excessive salt, and partially hydrogenated Oil.

By blending your own nut butter, you can naturally deviate from this heath pitfall.

The new conflict presented when blending nut butter is using the strongest high-speed blender on the market to get the job done (i.e. runny nut butter).

Have you ever placed almonds into a blender and continued to blend for HOURS because the nut never transitioned from the cookie dough consistency to the running butter consistency?

Well we did the research for you and found the best blender for nut buttter.

In this article, we will explore the Top 3 Best Blenders for Nut Butter and provide our honest opinion on the best appliance.

Best Blenders for nut butter tried and tested 2022.

We purchased and utilized three blenders for this experiment.

1. Vitamix
2. Hamilton Beach
3. Nutribullet

Control Group: Almonds

To make this experiment highly effective, we utilized roasted almonds as the control group.

• We used raw almonds from Whole Foods and roasted the nut for 10 minutes at 375 degrees Fahrenheit.
• We allowed the roasted almonds to cool for 20 minutes before blending.
• Each blender for nut butter received 2 cups of roasted almonds.
• We blended until the nut butter became runny (or close to runny).

Let’s get into the science!

Hamilton Beach

First up, we tested the famous Hamilton Beach food processor. Here are the pros and con’s

Time to Blend Nut Butter: 3 minutes

Pros

• Large capacity – 10 cups
• Easy to clean
• Easy to scrape the nut butter out of the container
• Blend with the press of 1 button
• No physical activity to blend
• Suction on the base of the machine
• Runny almond butter
• Almond butter ready in 3 minutes

Cons

• Not necessarily easy to store
• Only 3 speeds
• The lid does not lock securely
• Very loud

Nutribullet

Second, in line is the Nutribullet. If it wasn’t for this experiment, we would never be caught dead using a Nutribullet. Here are the pros and cons…

Time to Blend Nut Butter: 10+ Minutes

Pros

• Great design for storage
• Modern look
• Smaller container – good for blending sauces

Cons

• Extremely labor intensive to blend.
• Blend, stop, untwist lid, mix, seuree lid, blend method
• Takes a long time to blend (10+ minutes)
• Terrible cookie dough texture. Never becomes runny almond butter

Vitamix

Finally, the Vitamix. Our all-time favorite blender. The high-speed blender can do anything – juice, blend, crush, pulse, liquidate, etc. Of course, it can even blend through a raw almond. Here are the pros and cons.

Time to Blend Nut Butter: 4 Minutes

Pros

• Great design for storage
• Cleans itself
• Blending capabilities are endless
• Runny almond butter

Cons

• Loud
• Labor intensive – pressing the tamper into the blades
• Expensive, but an amazing investment

What is the best blender for nut butter?

Best Blender for Nut Butter: Hamilton Beach ($63)

In our opinion, the best blender for nut butter is Hamilton Beach.

The texture is smooth and runny. It only takes 3 minutes to blend to the perfect consistency and all you have to do is hit a button.

No physical labor is involved.

Finally, the price point is budget friendly sitting at $63 on amazon.

It’s a win-win across the board.

Check out Hamilton Beach here.

Second Best Blender for Nut Butter: Vitamix ($390)

In an extremely close second place is Vitamix.

We love Vitamix for a variety of reasons. It transformed raw almonds into smooth almond butter in 4 minutes.

The tamper design ensures the almonds hit the blades and blend properly.

However, the manual labor that goes into moving the tamper is less desirable when comparing it to the Hamilton Beach Food Processor.

The texture is incredibly smooth and it only takes 4 minutes to blend to the perfect consistency.

We highly recommend investing in a high-speed blender like the Vitamix because not only does it nut butter, but it also makes thick smoothie bowls, ice cream, salsa, soups, sauces, mixed drinks, chops veggies, and juices.

It’s an all-in-one appliance and takes up a small amount of space in your kitchen. It changed our lives and we hope it changes your life too!

Check out the Vitamix here.

Worst Blender for Nut Butter: Nutribullet ($82)

Finally, in last place is the Nutribullet, a blender that does not have the ability to shred a raw almond and transform it into nut butter.

If you want to waste 10+ minutes of your life watching your almonds turn into unusable cookie dough, then, by all means, we suggest the Nutribullet.

The texture is crumbly and it takes way too long to blend.

Overall, raw almonds or other nuts are not exactly cheap. If you want to throw your money down the drain and create odd nut butter, then the Nutribullet is for you.

Take our word, don’t buy a Nutribullet for nut butter.

However, the Nutribullet is GREAT for single-serve smoothies or sauces.

Some blenders are great at making just one thing – in this case, the Nutribullet falls into that category.

FAQ

What should I do with nut butter?

Check out some of our favorite recipes!

• Double Chocolate Sea Salt Brownies (Gluten Free & Dairy-free)
• Double Chocolate Chip Protein Cookies (Gluten Free & Vegan)

Why is there palm oil in peanut butter or almond butter? Is palm oil in nut butter bad?

Take a look at the ingredient list on your favorite jar of nut butter. You might notice Palm Oil included as an ingredient.

Many times, manufacuteres use palm oil to enhance flavor or improve the texture provide of the nut butter.

In other words, when you open a jar of nut butter and the texture of the nut butter is smooth, running, and easily stirrable, then there might be added (and unneeded) oils to the jar.

It is important to note that palm oil used in nut butter is oxidized (processed), which is why it provides no useful nutrition or flavor, as well as possible negative health effects.

There have been studies linking processed palm oil to psychological and biochemical health issues, including reproductive problems and organ toxicity, affecting kidney and lung function.

Why is there sugar in my nut butter jar?

Unfortunately, many processed jars of nut butter included added refined sugar to enhance the flavor.

It’s sad because many times consumers do not even check the label because it seems bizarre to add REFINED SUGAR to a jar of nut butter.

However, many brands love to sneak in this devilish ingredient, even Whole foods.